Articles | Volume 20, issue 11
https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-20-6767-2026
© Author(s) 2026. This work is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Seasonal biases induced by illumination changes and shadow casting in remote sensing derived glacier flow velocities
Download
- Final revised paper (published on 20 Nov 2026)
- Supplement to the final revised paper
- Preprint (discussion started on 04 Mar 2026)
Interactive discussion
Status: closed
Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor
| : Report abuse
-
RC1: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-946', Anonymous Referee #1, 06 Apr 2026
- AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Laurane Charrier, 31 Jul 2026
- AC3: 'Reply on RC1', Laurane Charrier, 12 Aug 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on egusphere-2026-946', Whyjay Zheng, 16 May 2026
- AC2: 'Reply on RC2', Laurane Charrier, 31 Jul 2026
Peer review completion
AR – Author's response | RR – Referee report | ED – Editor decision | EF – Editorial file upload
ED: Submit a revised manuscript (24 Aug 2026) by Wesley Van Wychen
AR by Laurane Charrier on behalf of the Authors (25 Aug 2026)
Author's response
Author's tracked changes
Manuscript
ED: Reconsider after major revisions (further review by editor and referees) (08 Sep 2026) by Wesley Van Wychen
ED: Referee Nomination & Report Request started (22 Sep 2026) by Wesley Van Wychen
RR by Anonymous Referee #1 (07 Oct 2026)
RR by Whyjay Zheng (11 Oct 2026)
ED: Publish subject to technical corrections (15 Oct 2026) by Wesley Van Wychen
AR by Laurane Charrier on behalf of the Authors (16 Oct 2026)
Manuscript
General comments
This paper provides a useful review of the impact of terrain shadowing on the determination of glacier velocities from optical remote sensing, demonstrating that there is a potentially strong seasonal dependency (mainly related to surface slope and aspect). The use of simultaneously-acquired in situ GNSS data at Argentiere Glacier helps to strengthen the arguments. This is a topic which has been little investigated before, but the results demonstrate that it should be included when using remote-sensing derived glacier velocities
The first part of the paper is generally well written, well illustrated, and easy to follow. However, the final part of the paper (particularly sections 4.4 and 5) are much less well developed and explained, and need some work to bring them up to the standard of the rest of the manuscript. I provide detailed comments below to help with this.
Specific comments
The title could be made more informative by including mention of shadows. When I first read it I expected seasonal biases to also discuss things such as the effect of seasonal snow, but this isn’t included.
L19: I’m unclear as to what this sentence is referring to: ‘the measured velocities still reflect shadow tracking in areas affected by shadow casting’. In particular, is this reflecting to errors computed over static areas, or over moving glaciers? Please clarify.
L23: change ‘evidences’ to ‘evidence’
L27: should make it clear here that it’s the resolution of newly available optical and SAR satellite imagery that’s important (i.e., high enough to detect glacier motion over short timescales), in addition to the number of images and their repeat cycle
L43: It may also be useful to mention that there are inherent biases in the availability of glacier velocity data based on the sensor used: e.g., SAR imagery is best for winter imagery and accumulation areas; optical imagery is best for summer imagery and ablation areas.
L57: would be useful to include a map of your study area which shows the locations you refer to in the text (e.g., Argentiere Glacier, Bossons Glacier), and highlights some of the features (e.g., steep slopes, shadowing, location of GNSS antenna). An inset photo of Argentiere Glacier might also be useful to include to show the steepness of the surrounding topography. Fig. A2 could provide a good starting point for this, but with more information included.
L119: I think this should read: ‘focus only on the seasonal variations in section 4.1’?
L147: change to ‘by an exponential decay”
L158: add am to the time here (10:30 am) to avoid any ambiguity, and to be consistent with the format used on L168. Also check for similar issues elsewhere (e.g., L109)
L158: you state here that 10:30 local time corresponds to the time of acquisition of Sentinel-2 images. However, L109 states that Sentinel-2 acquisitions occur at 10:30 UTC, which is 2 hrs behind local time in France in the summer and 1 hr behind local time in the winter. These statements therefore need to be corrected, and/or the shadow calculations need to be redone to match up with the actual Sentinel-2 acquisition time.
L223: provides units for 29 and 55 (presumably m yr-1?)
L251: change ‘shadow extend’ to ‘shadow extent’
Fig. 5 caption: I don’t know what this is referring to: “Shadow casting is illustrated on two Sentinel-2 images in Fig. 5”. Perhaps the reference here is meant to be to Fig. B7?
L294/5: this needs a bit more explanation as to exactly what role the DEM co-registration played in the Provost (2025) study of Aletsch Glacier
L298: I find this entire section 4.4 awkwardly worded and difficult to follow (additional comments are below). The sentences and thoughts seem to be disconnected from each other, and I can’t tell what exactly you’ve done compared to what you’re proposing to do, and how this relates to the findings of your study. Please reword/clarify this section!
L299: this sentence reads like an incomplete thought. Do you actually implement what you propose here? Needs better explanation.
L302: I don’t understand why Combe Maudite is specifically mentioned here, when it isn’t mentioned anywhere else in the manuscript.
L307: this is a weird way to start a paragraph. Does the first sentence connect to the previous paragraph? The second sentence says that you propose something, but I can’t tell whether you actually implement this.
L319: it seems that you’ve forgotten to provide any reference to Fig. 8 in this section, which is important to understand what’s being referred to. This section 5 also needs expanding to much better explain your methods and input data sources for computing the stated seasonal biases. Some of this information is included in the caption for Fig. 8 (e.g., that you used ITS_LIVE image-pair velocities), but this also needs to be in the main text.
Fig. 8: I have a few significant concerns about this figure (not helped by the fact that the methodology to produce it is not properly described – see previous comment):
Fig. B4 caption: state that the blue dot is on Bossons Glacier
Fig. B7 caption: state that the point is on Bossons Glacier