Dear authors,

Thank you for your responses to the reviewers concerns. Please upload your revised manuscript. Due to the mixed opinions I'll let this manuscript go out for a second review.

Best regards,

Josefin

Dear authors,

Thank you for your revised manuscript which has now been reviewed. The reviewers are overall positive after your implemented changes.

I suggest that you make the following changes to account for one of the reviewers concerns:
1) Make sure conclusions reflects the updated data
2) Clarify the explanation of how you made figure 1
3) Make the limits and uncertainties of your model very clear to the reader. One reviewer is concerned about the applicability of your methods to the Amery Ice Shelf, rather than a more general setting. I think you can keep the Amery ice shelf as long as you very clearly state the the potential caveats of that.

With the above changes, I believe the paper is ready for publication.

Best regards,

Josefin Ahlkrona

Dear authors,

Thank you for your thorough revision of the paper, which I am glad to accept for publication,

Best regards