E. Bueler
Intercomparison should include measurement of differences, between model results and observations, among the model results themselves, or between model results and exact solutions. The processes of measuring differences and critically analyzing those differences are vital. Without such measurement as a component of intercomparison, the only expected benefits of an intercomparison project are participation, possibly the discovery of communal confusion, and the establishment of public, non-proprietary data sets.
Received: 21 Apr 2008 – Discussion started: 29 May 2008
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
E. Bueler
Viewed
Total article views: 2,048 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,489
428
131
2,048
122
123
HTML: 1,489
PDF: 428
XML: 131
Total: 2,048
BibTeX: 122
EndNote: 123
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
2
3
0
5
Mar 2013
5
8
1
14
Apr 2013
2
4
0
6
May 2013
6
8
0
14
Jun 2013
5
6
1
12
Jul 2013
1
5
0
6
Aug 2013
4
4
0
8
Sep 2013
2
4
0
6
Oct 2013
6
8
0
14
Nov 2013
12
5
1
18
Dec 2013
8
7
1
16
Jan 2014
14
6
3
23
Feb 2014
6
9
3
18
Mar 2014
14
11
3
28
Apr 2014
8
9
1
18
May 2014
16
12
2
30
Jun 2014
2
4
0
6
Jul 2014
7
14
1
22
Aug 2014
5
8
0
13
Sep 2014
10
0
10
Oct 2014
9
10
0
19
Nov 2014
10
14
0
24
Dec 2014
4
12
2
18
Jan 2015
2
5
1
8
Feb 2015
7
3
1
11
Mar 2015
5
4
0
9
Apr 2015
11
2
1
14
May 2015
6
4
1
11
Jun 2015
8
0
8
Jul 2015
9
0
9
Aug 2015
3
2
0
5
Sep 2015
2
3
1
6
Oct 2015
10
4
7
21
Nov 2015
12
2
1
15
Dec 2015
1
2
0
3
Jan 2016
13
5
0
18
Feb 2016
19
7
0
26
Mar 2016
33
1
0
34
Apr 2016
11
5
0
16
May 2016
12
2
0
14
Jun 2016
7
0
7
Jul 2016
7
1
1
9
Aug 2016
5
3
0
8
Sep 2016
6
1
7
Oct 2016
15
1
3
19
Nov 2016
12
3
0
15
Dec 2016
8
1
0
9
Jan 2017
8
3
11
Feb 2017
17
8
25
Mar 2017
29
2
6
37
Apr 2017
35
1
9
45
May 2017
42
1
9
52
Jun 2017
31
1
6
38
Jul 2017
14
3
0
17
Aug 2017
7
1
0
8
Sep 2017
10
0
10
Oct 2017
9
0
9
Nov 2017
10
0
10
Dec 2017
10
2
0
12
Jan 2018
12
1
0
13
Feb 2018
19
3
3
25
Mar 2018
19
2
0
21
Apr 2018
9
2
0
11
May 2018
10
3
0
13
Jun 2018
2
1
0
3
Jul 2018
6
1
0
7
Aug 2018
8
3
0
11
Sep 2018
13
4
1
18
Oct 2018
13
2
0
15
Nov 2018
16
3
1
20
Dec 2018
6
3
0
9
Jan 2019
3
0
3
Feb 2019
7
2
0
9
Mar 2019
3
4
0
7
Apr 2019
5
6
0
11
May 2019
5
4
0
9
Jun 2019
4
3
0
7
Jul 2019
12
1
1
14
Aug 2019
8
4
1
13
Sep 2019
5
3
0
8
Oct 2019
9
1
10
Nov 2019
17
1
2
20
Dec 2019
19
2
0
21
Jan 2020
18
3
0
21
Feb 2020
15
2
1
18
Mar 2020
6
2
1
9
Apr 2020
6
0
6
May 2020
4
1
0
5
Jun 2020
5
1
0
6
Jul 2020
7
4
4
15
Aug 2020
5
4
2
11
Sep 2020
4
5
0
9
Oct 2020
10
5
0
15
Nov 2020
5
1
0
6
Dec 2020
6
3
1
10
Jan 2021
8
3
0
11
Feb 2021
7
1
0
8
Mar 2021
10
1
0
11
Apr 2021
9
0
9
May 2021
5
1
0
6
Jun 2021
13
4
0
17
Jul 2021
14
1
0
15
Aug 2021
10
3
1
14
Sep 2021
10
1
0
11
Oct 2021
7
2
0
9
Nov 2021
7
0
7
Dec 2021
9
4
0
13
Jan 2022
22
2
0
24
Feb 2022
14
3
2
19
Mar 2022
10
2
2
14
Apr 2022
11
0
11
May 2022
15
1
0
16
Jun 2022
9
1
0
10
Jul 2022
4
0
4
Aug 2022
3
2
0
5
Sep 2022
5
4
1
10
Oct 2022
7
2
0
9
Nov 2022
7
3
0
10
Dec 2022
14
2
1
17
Jan 2023
9
4
0
13
Feb 2023
13
2
0
15
Mar 2023
13
1
0
14
Apr 2023
2
0
2
May 2023
9
5
2
16
Jun 2023
15
6
1
22
Jul 2023
15
3
2
20
Aug 2023
8
2
1
11
Sep 2023
13
2
1
16
Oct 2023
18
1
1
20
Nov 2023
9
3
1
13
Dec 2023
21
1
1
23
Jan 2024
17
0
17
Feb 2024
22
0
22
Mar 2024
34
2
36
Apr 2024
12
3
8
23
May 2024
9
1
3
13
Jun 2024
15
3
2
20
Jul 2024
21
2
0
23
Aug 2024
30
1
31
Sep 2024
28
1
0
29
Oct 2024
10
3
1
14
Nov 2024
1
1
0
2
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
2
3
0
Mar 2013
7
11
1
Apr 2013
9
15
1
May 2013
15
23
1
Jun 2013
20
29
2
Jul 2013
21
34
2
Aug 2013
25
38
2
Sep 2013
27
42
2
Oct 2013
33
50
2
Nov 2013
45
55
3
Dec 2013
53
62
4
Jan 2014
67
68
7
Feb 2014
73
77
10
Mar 2014
87
88
13
Apr 2014
95
97
14
May 2014
111
109
16
Jun 2014
113
113
16
Jul 2014
120
127
17
Aug 2014
125
135
17
Sep 2014
125
145
17
Oct 2014
134
155
17
Nov 2014
144
169
17
Dec 2014
148
181
19
Jan 2015
150
186
20
Feb 2015
157
189
21
Mar 2015
162
193
21
Apr 2015
173
195
22
May 2015
179
199
23
Jun 2015
187
199
23
Jul 2015
196
199
23
Aug 2015
199
201
23
Sep 2015
201
204
24
Oct 2015
211
208
31
Nov 2015
223
210
32
Dec 2015
224
212
32
Jan 2016
237
217
32
Feb 2016
256
224
32
Mar 2016
289
225
32
Apr 2016
300
230
32
May 2016
312
232
32
Jun 2016
319
232
32
Jul 2016
326
233
33
Aug 2016
331
236
33
Sep 2016
337
236
34
Oct 2016
352
237
37
Nov 2016
364
240
37
Dec 2016
372
241
37
Jan 2017
380
241
40
Feb 2017
397
241
48
Mar 2017
426
243
54
Apr 2017
461
244
63
May 2017
503
245
72
Jun 2017
534
246
78
Jul 2017
548
249
78
Aug 2017
555
250
78
Sep 2017
565
250
78
Oct 2017
574
250
78
Nov 2017
584
250
78
Dec 2017
594
252
78
Jan 2018
606
253
78
Feb 2018
625
256
81
Mar 2018
644
258
81
Apr 2018
653
260
81
May 2018
663
263
81
Jun 2018
665
264
81
Jul 2018
671
265
81
Aug 2018
679
268
81
Sep 2018
692
272
82
Oct 2018
705
274
82
Nov 2018
721
277
83
Dec 2018
727
280
83
Jan 2019
730
280
83
Feb 2019
737
282
83
Mar 2019
740
286
83
Apr 2019
745
292
83
May 2019
750
296
83
Jun 2019
754
299
83
Jul 2019
766
300
84
Aug 2019
774
304
85
Sep 2019
779
307
85
Oct 2019
788
307
86
Nov 2019
805
308
88
Dec 2019
824
310
88
Jan 2020
842
313
88
Feb 2020
857
315
89
Mar 2020
863
317
90
Apr 2020
869
317
90
May 2020
873
318
90
Jun 2020
878
319
90
Jul 2020
885
323
94
Aug 2020
890
327
96
Sep 2020
894
332
96
Oct 2020
904
337
96
Nov 2020
909
338
96
Dec 2020
915
341
97
Jan 2021
923
344
97
Feb 2021
930
345
97
Mar 2021
940
346
97
Apr 2021
949
346
97
May 2021
954
347
97
Jun 2021
967
351
97
Jul 2021
981
352
97
Aug 2021
991
355
98
Sep 2021
1,001
356
98
Oct 2021
1,008
358
98
Nov 2021
1,015
358
98
Dec 2021
1,024
362
98
Jan 2022
1,046
364
98
Feb 2022
1,060
367
100
Mar 2022
1,070
369
102
Apr 2022
1,081
369
102
May 2022
1,096
370
102
Jun 2022
1,105
371
102
Jul 2022
1,109
371
102
Aug 2022
1,112
373
102
Sep 2022
1,117
377
103
Oct 2022
1,124
379
103
Nov 2022
1,131
382
103
Dec 2022
1,145
384
104
Jan 2023
1,154
388
104
Feb 2023
1,167
390
104
Mar 2023
1,180
391
104
Apr 2023
1,182
391
104
May 2023
1,191
396
106
Jun 2023
1,206
402
107
Jul 2023
1,221
405
109
Aug 2023
1,229
407
110
Sep 2023
1,242
409
111
Oct 2023
1,260
410
112
Nov 2023
1,269
413
113
Dec 2023
1,290
414
114
Jan 2024
1,307
414
114
Feb 2024
1,329
414
114
Mar 2024
1,363
414
116
Apr 2024
1,375
417
124
May 2024
1,384
418
127
Jun 2024
1,399
421
129
Jul 2024
1,420
423
129
Aug 2024
1,450
423
130
Sep 2024
1,478
424
130
Oct 2024
1,488
427
131
Nov 2024
1,489
428
131
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 15 Nov 2024