|
01 Jul 2013
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal TC but the revision was not accepted.
Technical Note: On the use of the mushy-layer Rayleigh number for the interpretation of sea-ice-core data
M. Vancoppenolle , D. Notz , F. Vivier , J. Tison , B. Delille , G. Carnat , J. Zhou , F. Jardon , P. Griewank , A. Lourenço , and T. Haskell
We examine some practical aspects of using a mushy-layer Rayleigh number for the interpretation of sea-ice-core data. In principle, such analysis should allow one to determine convectively active regions within the ice core by identifying those regions in which the mush-Rayleigh number is super-critical. In practice, however, a quantitative analysis is complicated by uncertainties regarding the specific formulation of both the mush-Rayleigh number itself and of the sea-ice permeability that is crucial for quantifying the Rayleigh number. Additionally, brine loss from highly permeable sections of the ice core, in particular close to the ice–ocean interface, and typically weekly ice core sampling, limit the practical applicability of the Rayleigh number for ice-core interpretation. We here quantify these uncertainties, suggest a standard method for the computation of the Rayleigh number for sea ice and discuss possibilities and limitations of ice-core interpretation based on the Rayleigh number.
Received: 17 Jun 2013 – Discussion started: 01 Jul 2013
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this preprint. The responsibility to include appropriate place names lies with the authors.
M. Vancoppenolle , D. Notz , F. Vivier , J. Tison , B. Delille , G. Carnat , J. Zhou , F. Jardon , P. Griewank , A. Lourenço , and T. Haskell
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
M. Vancoppenolle , D. Notz , F. Vivier , J. Tison , B. Delille , G. Carnat , J. Zhou , F. Jardon , P. Griewank , A. Lourenço , and T. Haskell
M. Vancoppenolle , D. Notz , F. Vivier , J. Tison , B. Delille , G. Carnat , J. Zhou , F. Jardon , P. Griewank , A. Lourenço , and T. Haskell
Viewed
Total article views: 2,625 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
1,598
749
278
2,625
127
145
HTML: 1,598
PDF: 749
XML: 278
Total: 2,625
BibTeX: 127
EndNote: 145
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Jul 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Jul 2013
68
43
5
116
Aug 2013
8
13
0
21
Sep 2013
9
26
2
37
Oct 2013
13
10
0
23
Nov 2013
5
7
1
13
Dec 2013
10
11
1
22
Jan 2014
15
15
3
33
Feb 2014
8
11
5
24
Mar 2014
10
18
2
30
Apr 2014
12
13
2
27
May 2014
13
14
0
27
Jun 2014
5
7
0
12
Jul 2014
6
15
0
21
Aug 2014
1
10
0
11
Sep 2014
4
11
0
15
Oct 2014
4
10
0
14
Nov 2014
1
5
0
6
Dec 2014
2
10
0
12
Jan 2015
6
8
1
15
Feb 2015
7
2
1
10
Mar 2015
5
5
0
10
Apr 2015
11
5
1
17
May 2015
2
3
0
5
Jun 2015
6
9
0
15
Jul 2015
9
4
0
13
Aug 2015
2
7
0
9
Sep 2015
5
4
0
9
Oct 2015
8
6
7
21
Nov 2015
6
5
0
11
Dec 2015
3
6
0
9
Jan 2016
8
5
0
13
Feb 2016
9
3
0
12
Mar 2016
31
3
0
34
Apr 2016
5
2
0
7
May 2016
16
9
0
25
Jun 2016
4
2
0
6
Jul 2016
6
1
2
9
Aug 2016
7
3
2
12
Sep 2016
10
3
1
14
Oct 2016
15
2
17
Nov 2016
12
4
0
16
Dec 2016
8
0
8
Jan 2017
19
4
23
Feb 2017
25
1
8
34
Mar 2017
42
2
9
53
Apr 2017
45
4
10
59
May 2017
44
9
9
62
Jun 2017
32
2
7
41
Jul 2017
11
2
0
13
Aug 2017
10
3
0
13
Sep 2017
9
1
0
10
Oct 2017
9
0
9
Nov 2017
14
0
14
Dec 2017
11
3
0
14
Jan 2018
16
1
0
17
Feb 2018
20
1
3
24
Mar 2018
12
2
0
14
Apr 2018
16
2
1
19
May 2018
16
4
0
20
Jun 2018
15
2
0
17
Jul 2018
18
2
0
20
Aug 2018
20
4
0
24
Sep 2018
24
6
0
30
Oct 2018
20
7
2
29
Nov 2018
31
3
0
34
Dec 2018
8
6
0
14
Jan 2019
4
2
0
6
Feb 2019
2
2
0
4
Mar 2019
6
4
0
10
Apr 2019
7
4
0
11
May 2019
5
3
0
8
Jun 2019
5
5
0
10
Jul 2019
11
10
1
22
Aug 2019
6
8
0
14
Sep 2019
5
4
0
9
Oct 2019
6
2
0
8
Nov 2019
16
6
2
24
Dec 2019
8
2
0
10
Jan 2020
17
6
0
23
Feb 2020
15
3
0
18
Mar 2020
6
4
1
11
Apr 2020
3
0
3
May 2020
6
4
0
10
Jun 2020
5
1
0
6
Jul 2020
14
8
5
27
Aug 2020
1
2
2
5
Sep 2020
2
4
0
6
Oct 2020
3
2
0
5
Nov 2020
3
1
3
7
Dec 2020
5
3
1
9
Jan 2021
7
6
0
13
Feb 2021
8
4
33
45
Mar 2021
4
3
91
98
Apr 2021
7
5
0
12
May 2021
5
2
0
7
Jun 2021
10
3
0
13
Jul 2021
12
1
0
13
Aug 2021
10
6
1
17
Sep 2021
10
2
0
12
Oct 2021
12
3
0
15
Nov 2021
15
4
0
19
Dec 2021
10
5
0
15
Jan 2022
25
6
0
31
Feb 2022
18
3
3
24
Mar 2022
14
5
3
22
Apr 2022
15
3
1
19
May 2022
10
2
0
12
Jun 2022
4
4
0
8
Jul 2022
8
4
0
12
Aug 2022
11
4
2
17
Sep 2022
6
4
0
10
Oct 2022
8
3
1
12
Nov 2022
14
9
1
24
Dec 2022
16
7
1
24
Jan 2023
3
2
0
5
Feb 2023
11
5
1
17
Mar 2023
13
7
1
21
Apr 2023
3
6
1
10
May 2023
6
9
1
16
Jun 2023
9
9
2
20
Jul 2023
11
6
3
20
Aug 2023
10
11
3
24
Sep 2023
9
9
1
19
Oct 2023
10
13
3
26
Nov 2023
13
8
1
22
Dec 2023
15
4
0
19
Jan 2024
14
10
0
24
Feb 2024
16
3
0
19
Mar 2024
17
6
3
26
Apr 2024
16
8
4
28
May 2024
16
6
1
23
Jun 2024
27
2
3
32
Jul 2024
8
6
1
15
Aug 2024
36
1
3
40
Sep 2024
22
6
1
29
Oct 2024
8
6
2
16
Nov 2024
3
3
0
6
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Jul 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Jul 2013
68
43
5
Aug 2013
76
56
5
Sep 2013
85
82
7
Oct 2013
98
92
7
Nov 2013
103
99
8
Dec 2013
113
110
9
Jan 2014
128
125
12
Feb 2014
136
136
17
Mar 2014
146
154
19
Apr 2014
158
167
21
May 2014
171
181
21
Jun 2014
176
188
21
Jul 2014
182
203
21
Aug 2014
183
213
21
Sep 2014
187
224
21
Oct 2014
191
234
21
Nov 2014
192
239
21
Dec 2014
194
249
21
Jan 2015
200
257
22
Feb 2015
207
259
23
Mar 2015
212
264
23
Apr 2015
223
269
24
May 2015
225
272
24
Jun 2015
231
281
24
Jul 2015
240
285
24
Aug 2015
242
292
24
Sep 2015
247
296
24
Oct 2015
255
302
31
Nov 2015
261
307
31
Dec 2015
264
313
31
Jan 2016
272
318
31
Feb 2016
281
321
31
Mar 2016
312
324
31
Apr 2016
317
326
31
May 2016
333
335
31
Jun 2016
337
337
31
Jul 2016
343
338
33
Aug 2016
350
341
35
Sep 2016
360
344
36
Oct 2016
375
344
38
Nov 2016
387
348
38
Dec 2016
395
348
38
Jan 2017
414
348
42
Feb 2017
439
349
50
Mar 2017
481
351
59
Apr 2017
526
355
69
May 2017
570
364
78
Jun 2017
602
366
85
Jul 2017
613
368
85
Aug 2017
623
371
85
Sep 2017
632
372
85
Oct 2017
641
372
85
Nov 2017
655
372
85
Dec 2017
666
375
85
Jan 2018
682
376
85
Feb 2018
702
377
88
Mar 2018
714
379
88
Apr 2018
730
381
89
May 2018
746
385
89
Jun 2018
761
387
89
Jul 2018
779
389
89
Aug 2018
799
393
89
Sep 2018
823
399
89
Oct 2018
843
406
91
Nov 2018
874
409
91
Dec 2018
882
415
91
Jan 2019
886
417
91
Feb 2019
888
419
91
Mar 2019
894
423
91
Apr 2019
901
427
91
May 2019
906
430
91
Jun 2019
911
435
91
Jul 2019
922
445
92
Aug 2019
928
453
92
Sep 2019
933
457
92
Oct 2019
939
459
92
Nov 2019
955
465
94
Dec 2019
963
467
94
Jan 2020
980
473
94
Feb 2020
995
476
94
Mar 2020
1,001
480
95
Apr 2020
1,004
480
95
May 2020
1,010
484
95
Jun 2020
1,015
485
95
Jul 2020
1,029
493
100
Aug 2020
1,030
495
102
Sep 2020
1,032
499
102
Oct 2020
1,035
501
102
Nov 2020
1,038
502
105
Dec 2020
1,043
505
106
Jan 2021
1,050
511
106
Feb 2021
1,058
515
139
Mar 2021
1,062
518
230
Apr 2021
1,069
523
230
May 2021
1,074
525
230
Jun 2021
1,084
528
230
Jul 2021
1,096
529
230
Aug 2021
1,106
535
231
Sep 2021
1,116
537
231
Oct 2021
1,128
540
231
Nov 2021
1,143
544
231
Dec 2021
1,153
549
231
Jan 2022
1,178
555
231
Feb 2022
1,196
558
234
Mar 2022
1,210
563
237
Apr 2022
1,225
566
238
May 2022
1,235
568
238
Jun 2022
1,239
572
238
Jul 2022
1,247
576
238
Aug 2022
1,258
580
240
Sep 2022
1,264
584
240
Oct 2022
1,272
587
241
Nov 2022
1,286
596
242
Dec 2022
1,302
603
243
Jan 2023
1,305
605
243
Feb 2023
1,316
610
244
Mar 2023
1,329
617
245
Apr 2023
1,332
623
246
May 2023
1,338
632
247
Jun 2023
1,347
641
249
Jul 2023
1,358
647
252
Aug 2023
1,368
658
255
Sep 2023
1,377
667
256
Oct 2023
1,387
680
259
Nov 2023
1,400
688
260
Dec 2023
1,415
692
260
Jan 2024
1,429
702
260
Feb 2024
1,445
705
260
Mar 2024
1,462
711
263
Apr 2024
1,478
719
267
May 2024
1,494
725
268
Jun 2024
1,521
727
271
Jul 2024
1,529
733
272
Aug 2024
1,565
734
275
Sep 2024
1,587
740
276
Oct 2024
1,595
746
278
Nov 2024
1,598
749
278
Cited
Saved
Latest update: 18 Nov 2024