|
20 Dec 2010
Status : this preprint was under review for the journal TC but the revision was not accepted.
Reply to the Comment of Leclercq et al. on "100-year mass changes in the Swiss Alps linked to the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation"
M. Huss , R. Hock , A. Bauder , and M. Funk
In their comment, Leclercq et al. argue that Huss et al. (2010) overestimate the effect of the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO) on the 100-year mass balance variations in the Swiss Alps because time series of conventional balances instead of reference-surface balances were used. Applying the same model as in Huss et al. we calculate time series of reference-surface mass balance, and show that the difference between conventional and reference-surface mass balance is significantly smaller than stated in the comment. Both series exhibit very similar multidecadal variations. The opposing effects of retreat and surface lowering on mass balance partly cancel each other.
Received: 26 Nov 2010 – Discussion started: 20 Dec 2010
Publisher's note : Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
M. Huss , R. Hock , A. Bauder , and M. Funk
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
Status: closed
Status: closed
AC : Author comment | RC : Referee comment | SC : Short comment | EC : Editor comment
- Printer-friendly version
- Supplement
M. Huss , R. Hock , A. Bauder , and M. Funk
M. Huss , R. Hock , A. Bauder , and M. Funk
Viewed
Total article views: 4,149 (including HTML, PDF, and XML)
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
BibTeX
EndNote
3,249
753
147
4,149
156
185
HTML: 3,249
PDF: 753
XML: 147
Total: 4,149
BibTeX: 156
EndNote: 185
Views and downloads (calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML
PDF
XML
Total
Feb 2013
1
5
0
6
Mar 2013
2
13
1
16
Apr 2013
2
6
0
8
May 2013
3
15
0
18
Jun 2013
3
10
1
14
Jul 2013
1
6
0
7
Aug 2013
6
0
6
Sep 2013
1
6
0
7
Oct 2013
2
9
0
11
Nov 2013
1
10
0
11
Dec 2013
5
6
2
13
Jan 2014
7
6
2
15
Feb 2014
5
8
4
17
Mar 2014
8
9
2
19
Apr 2014
2
7
0
9
May 2014
2
8
1
11
Jun 2014
3
8
0
11
Jul 2014
6
8
2
16
Aug 2014
3
8
0
11
Sep 2014
9
0
9
Oct 2014
4
7
0
11
Nov 2014
4
6
0
10
Dec 2014
10
0
10
Jan 2015
1
3
0
4
Feb 2015
8
1
1
10
Mar 2015
4
2
0
6
Apr 2015
9
2
11
May 2015
2
3
0
5
Jun 2015
8
2
0
10
Jul 2015
7
0
7
Aug 2015
3
3
0
6
Sep 2015
2
2
0
4
Oct 2015
7
2
7
16
Nov 2015
6
2
0
8
Dec 2015
1
3
1
5
Jan 2016
11
5
0
16
Feb 2016
9
3
0
12
Mar 2016
31
2
0
33
Apr 2016
13
4
0
17
May 2016
13
2
0
15
Jun 2016
8
5
0
13
Jul 2016
5
3
1
9
Aug 2016
4
3
0
7
Sep 2016
10
2
1
13
Oct 2016
15
4
1
20
Nov 2016
13
4
1
18
Dec 2016
16
6
1
23
Jan 2017
32
9
3
44
Feb 2017
38
5
8
51
Mar 2017
63
9
9
81
Apr 2017
59
7
8
74
May 2017
66
7
9
82
Jun 2017
57
5
6
68
Jul 2017
30
9
0
39
Aug 2017
21
3
0
24
Sep 2017
30
2
0
32
Oct 2017
36
7
0
43
Nov 2017
36
6
0
42
Dec 2017
45
5
0
50
Jan 2018
38
5
0
43
Feb 2018
38
2
3
43
Mar 2018
36
14
0
50
Apr 2018
34
9
0
43
May 2018
37
7
1
45
Jun 2018
41
9
0
50
Jul 2018
30
7
0
37
Aug 2018
27
8
0
35
Sep 2018
38
6
0
44
Oct 2018
44
5
0
49
Nov 2018
47
6
0
53
Dec 2018
40
6
0
46
Jan 2019
32
4
0
36
Feb 2019
39
6
1
46
Mar 2019
36
6
1
43
Apr 2019
29
5
0
34
May 2019
30
2
0
32
Jun 2019
26
8
0
34
Jul 2019
41
10
0
51
Aug 2019
55
7
0
62
Sep 2019
48
9
0
57
Oct 2019
22
4
1
27
Nov 2019
36
4
1
41
Dec 2019
38
5
0
43
Jan 2020
67
13
0
80
Feb 2020
30
4
1
35
Mar 2020
19
3
1
23
Apr 2020
29
4
0
33
May 2020
18
4
0
22
Jun 2020
29
5
0
34
Jul 2020
26
5
5
36
Aug 2020
12
3
2
17
Sep 2020
16
6
0
22
Oct 2020
23
6
1
30
Nov 2020
18
7
1
26
Dec 2020
37
8
3
48
Jan 2021
38
9
1
48
Feb 2021
32
7
0
39
Mar 2021
35
7
0
42
Apr 2021
28
7
0
35
May 2021
45
12
3
60
Jun 2021
27
7
0
34
Jul 2021
26
8
0
34
Aug 2021
32
10
1
43
Sep 2021
9
1
0
10
Oct 2021
30
9
0
39
Nov 2021
17
5
0
22
Dec 2021
4
2
0
6
Jan 2022
14
5
0
19
Feb 2022
11
5
2
18
Mar 2022
4
2
2
8
Apr 2022
6
1
0
7
May 2022
5
4
0
9
Jun 2022
6
2
0
8
Jul 2022
2
0
2
Aug 2022
3
4
0
7
Sep 2022
6
3
0
9
Oct 2022
15
6
2
23
Nov 2022
22
4
0
26
Dec 2022
11
3
1
15
Jan 2023
7
1
0
8
Feb 2023
7
2
0
9
Mar 2023
11
2
0
13
Apr 2023
4
2
1
7
May 2023
8
6
1
15
Jun 2023
11
3
1
15
Jul 2023
18
2
2
22
Aug 2023
5
1
1
7
Sep 2023
11
2
1
14
Oct 2023
9
1
0
10
Nov 2023
8
1
1
10
Dec 2023
6
1
1
8
Jan 2024
10
1
11
Feb 2024
12
4
0
16
Mar 2024
29
2
1
32
Apr 2024
15
2
3
20
May 2024
13
1
3
17
Jun 2024
17
3
2
22
Jul 2024
16
4
2
22
Aug 2024
36
2
1
39
Sep 2024
21
0
21
Oct 2024
12
4
2
18
Nov 2024
5
2
1
8
Dec 2024
2
0
2
Jan 2025
9
3
1
13
Feb 2025
22
1
23
Mar 2025
18
3
2
23
Apr 2025
13
4
2
19
May 2025
16
4
1
21
Jun 2025
23
0
23
Jul 2025
21
2
3
26
Aug 2025
102
3
1
106
Sep 2025
279
4
0
283
Oct 2025
16
1
0
17
Nov 2025
19
10
3
32
Cumulative views and downloads
(calculated since 01 Feb 2013)
Month
HTML views
PDF downloads
XML downloads
Feb 2013
1
5
0
Mar 2013
3
18
1
Apr 2013
5
24
1
May 2013
8
39
1
Jun 2013
11
49
2
Jul 2013
12
55
2
Aug 2013
12
61
2
Sep 2013
13
67
2
Oct 2013
15
76
2
Nov 2013
16
86
2
Dec 2013
21
92
4
Jan 2014
28
98
6
Feb 2014
33
106
10
Mar 2014
41
115
12
Apr 2014
43
122
12
May 2014
45
130
13
Jun 2014
48
138
13
Jul 2014
54
146
15
Aug 2014
57
154
15
Sep 2014
57
163
15
Oct 2014
61
170
15
Nov 2014
65
176
15
Dec 2014
65
186
15
Jan 2015
66
189
15
Feb 2015
74
190
16
Mar 2015
78
192
16
Apr 2015
87
192
18
May 2015
89
195
18
Jun 2015
97
197
18
Jul 2015
104
197
18
Aug 2015
107
200
18
Sep 2015
109
202
18
Oct 2015
116
204
25
Nov 2015
122
206
25
Dec 2015
123
209
26
Jan 2016
134
214
26
Feb 2016
143
217
26
Mar 2016
174
219
26
Apr 2016
187
223
26
May 2016
200
225
26
Jun 2016
208
230
26
Jul 2016
213
233
27
Aug 2016
217
236
27
Sep 2016
227
238
28
Oct 2016
242
242
29
Nov 2016
255
246
30
Dec 2016
271
252
31
Jan 2017
303
261
34
Feb 2017
341
266
42
Mar 2017
404
275
51
Apr 2017
463
282
59
May 2017
529
289
68
Jun 2017
586
294
74
Jul 2017
616
303
74
Aug 2017
637
306
74
Sep 2017
667
308
74
Oct 2017
703
315
74
Nov 2017
739
321
74
Dec 2017
784
326
74
Jan 2018
822
331
74
Feb 2018
860
333
77
Mar 2018
896
347
77
Apr 2018
930
356
77
May 2018
967
363
78
Jun 2018
1,008
372
78
Jul 2018
1,038
379
78
Aug 2018
1,065
387
78
Sep 2018
1,103
393
78
Oct 2018
1,147
398
78
Nov 2018
1,194
404
78
Dec 2018
1,234
410
78
Jan 2019
1,266
414
78
Feb 2019
1,305
420
79
Mar 2019
1,341
426
80
Apr 2019
1,370
431
80
May 2019
1,400
433
80
Jun 2019
1,426
441
80
Jul 2019
1,467
451
80
Aug 2019
1,522
458
80
Sep 2019
1,570
467
80
Oct 2019
1,592
471
81
Nov 2019
1,628
475
82
Dec 2019
1,666
480
82
Jan 2020
1,733
493
82
Feb 2020
1,763
497
83
Mar 2020
1,782
500
84
Apr 2020
1,811
504
84
May 2020
1,829
508
84
Jun 2020
1,858
513
84
Jul 2020
1,884
518
89
Aug 2020
1,896
521
91
Sep 2020
1,912
527
91
Oct 2020
1,935
533
92
Nov 2020
1,953
540
93
Dec 2020
1,990
548
96
Jan 2021
2,028
557
97
Feb 2021
2,060
564
97
Mar 2021
2,095
571
97
Apr 2021
2,123
578
97
May 2021
2,168
590
100
Jun 2021
2,195
597
100
Jul 2021
2,221
605
100
Aug 2021
2,253
615
101
Sep 2021
2,262
616
101
Oct 2021
2,292
625
101
Nov 2021
2,309
630
101
Dec 2021
2,313
632
101
Jan 2022
2,327
637
101
Feb 2022
2,338
642
103
Mar 2022
2,342
644
105
Apr 2022
2,348
645
105
May 2022
2,353
649
105
Jun 2022
2,359
651
105
Jul 2022
2,361
651
105
Aug 2022
2,364
655
105
Sep 2022
2,370
658
105
Oct 2022
2,385
664
107
Nov 2022
2,407
668
107
Dec 2022
2,418
671
108
Jan 2023
2,425
672
108
Feb 2023
2,432
674
108
Mar 2023
2,443
676
108
Apr 2023
2,447
678
109
May 2023
2,455
684
110
Jun 2023
2,466
687
111
Jul 2023
2,484
689
113
Aug 2023
2,489
690
114
Sep 2023
2,500
692
115
Oct 2023
2,509
693
115
Nov 2023
2,517
694
116
Dec 2023
2,523
695
117
Jan 2024
2,533
695
118
Feb 2024
2,545
699
118
Mar 2024
2,574
701
119
Apr 2024
2,589
703
122
May 2024
2,602
704
125
Jun 2024
2,619
707
127
Jul 2024
2,635
711
129
Aug 2024
2,671
713
130
Sep 2024
2,692
713
130
Oct 2024
2,704
717
132
Nov 2024
2,709
719
133
Dec 2024
2,711
719
133
Jan 2025
2,720
722
134
Feb 2025
2,742
722
135
Mar 2025
2,760
725
137
Apr 2025
2,773
729
139
May 2025
2,789
733
140
Jun 2025
2,812
733
140
Jul 2025
2,833
735
143
Aug 2025
2,935
738
144
Sep 2025
3,214
742
144
Oct 2025
3,230
743
144
Nov 2025
3,249
753
147
Latest update: 28 Nov 2025