the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Evaluation of the role of the Baltic depression during deglaciation of the last Scandinavian Ice Sheet; a landform-driven investigation
Jakub Z. Kalita
Christiaan R. Diemont
Stephen J. Livingstone
Chris D. Clark
Martin Margold
Abstract. Landforms left behind by the last Scandinavian Ice Sheet (SIS) offer an opportunity to investigate controls governing ice sheet dynamics. Terrestrial sectors of the ice sheet have received considerable attention by landform and stratigraphic investigations, but much less so for marine areas such as in the Baltic Sea. In contrast, despite its geographical importance, the Baltic Sea remain poorly constrained due to limitations in bathymetric data. The Baltic depression hosted the extensive Baltic Ice Lake, which likely exerted a considerable control on ice dynamics, providing an aqueous calving front that might have resulted in rapid collapse of this ice sheet sector. Both ice sheet scale investigations and regional studies at the southern periphery of the SIS have considered the Baltic depression as a preferential conduit for ice flux towards the southern ice margin throughout the last glaciation. Here we test this hypothesis using newly available bathymetric data and peripheral topographic data. For the first time, these data reveal an extensive landform suite stretching from Denmark in the west to Estonia in the east and from the southern European coast to the Aland Sea, comprising an area of 0.3 million km2. We use these landforms to reconstruct the ice dynamic history of the Baltic sector of the SIS. Landform evidence indicates a complex retreat pattern that changes from lobate ice margins with splaying lineations to parallel MSGL in the deeper depressions of the Baltic Basin. Ice margin still-stands on underlying geological structures indicate the likely importance of pinning points during deglaciation resulting in a stepped retreat signal. Over the length of the study area we identify broad changes in ice flow geometry, ranging from SE-NW to N-S and then to NW-SE. Mega-scale glacial lineations reveal distinct corridors of fast ice flow (ice streams) with widths of 30 up to 95 km, rather that the often-interpreted Baltic-wide (300 km) accelerated ice flow zone. These smaller ice streams are interpreted to have operated during late stages of deglaciation. Where previous ice sheet-scale investigations inferred a single ice source, our mapping identifies flow and ice marginal geometries from both Swedish and north Bothnian sources. We anticipate our landform mapping and interpretations may be used as a framework for more detailed empirical studies by identifying targets to acquire high resolution bathymetry and sediment cores and also for comparison with numerical ice sheet modelling.
- Preprint
(3745 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(17630 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Izabela Szuman et al.
Status: open (until 05 Oct 2023)
-
CC1: 'Comment on tc-2023-107', Margot Böse, 22 Aug 2023
reply
Dear authors,
you have done a lot of work of integrating morphological results from the Baltic Sea bottom and examples from adjacent areas. But at any case it is necessary to include the results from Rügen Island (Gehrmann and Kenzler c. f. ) as parts of the island have been strongly affected by glacitectonic processes from different directions. The citations you can find in Lüthgens et al. 2020, EGQSJ.
Margot Böse
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-2023-107-CC1 -
CC2: 'Comment on tc-2023-107', Sarah Greenwood, 06 Sep 2023
reply
Exploitation of newly available terrain datasets in the Baltic region is undoubtedly welcome, since the offshore sector was both dynamically important to the last ice sheet and highly under-researched. However, we identify a number of concerning problems with the work presented here, notably the quality and rigour of the landform mapping.
Please find details in the attached pdf. We comment only on internal issues in the manuscript. We do not discuss interpretations guided by any data not available to these authors, only what is presented as figures or text in the manuscript.
Sarah Greenwood, Carl Regnéll, Richard Gyllencreutz, Karol Tylmann
-
RC1: 'Comment on tc-2023-107', Anonymous Referee #1, 13 Sep 2023
reply
I think the scientific quality (rigour) falls between fair and good. Fair because evidence for some of the presented results are not convincing enough or alternative explanations not considered.
-
RC2: 'Comment on tc-2023-107', Anonymous Referee #2, 21 Sep 2023
reply
General comments:
This study is ambitious and the specific topic is highly relevant for the glacial dynamical development
of the Fennoscandian ice sheet.The manuscript is of a suitable length and its structure is proper, making it easy to crasp. However, I
agree with the comments of the anonymous referee and interactive comments by Greenwood et al.
The mapping procedure quality issues (misinterpretations), lack of use of geological maps and the
need for re-evaluation of some interpretations cause a need for major revisions.
Specific comments: (in order to minimize duplication, I will mainly comment only those points not
mentioned by Greenwood et al. or Anonymous referee)L25 (Abstract): “…broad changes in ice flow geometry, ranging from SE-NW to N-S and then to NWSE.”
<> Ice flow direction replacing ice flow geometry? And maybe with description of the flow
areas, for example: SE-NW in the western (SW of Malmö) area.L139_L146: terminology to be clarified: The unconsolidated sediments versus sedimentary rocks.
Also it is unclear what is meant with “soft sediments”L150: Elevation data => Bathymetric data?
L205: Soft sediment => unconsolidated sediment?
Technical corrections:
L77: “…from the south…”=> from towards the southL134 and L138: “…north-western Baltic…” and “…SE Baltic…” => north-western Baltic main basin and
SE Baltic main basin?Figure3B and 3D: conglometare => conglomerate (Is there a better word, for example bathymetric
data type margin etc.?)L429: could passed => could have passed
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-2023-107-RC2
Izabela Szuman et al.
Izabela Szuman et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
301 | 109 | 19 | 429 | 69 | 7 | 7 |
- HTML: 301
- PDF: 109
- XML: 19
- Total: 429
- Supplement: 69
- BibTeX: 7
- EndNote: 7
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1