"Black carbon concentrations from a Tibetan Plateau ice core spanning 1843-1982: recent increases due to emissions and glacier melt" - Interactive Discussion
http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/4855/2013/tcd-7-4855-2013-discussion.html
"Black carbon concentrations from a Tibetan Plateau ice core spanning 1843-1982: recent increases due to emissions and glacier melt" - Interactive DiscussionAC C2954: 'Normalized data as a solution to address data limitations', Susan Kaspari, 04 Jan 2014http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2954/2014/tcd-7-C2954-2014.pdfAC C2954: 'Normalized data as a solution to address data limitations', Susan Kaspari, 04 Jan 20142014-01-04T03:37:41+01:00AC C2952: 'Clarification regarding albedo reductions from BC in the presence of dust.', Susan Kaspari, 04 Jan 2014http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2952/2014/tcd-7-C2952-2014.pdfAC C2952: 'Clarification regarding albedo reductions from BC in the presence of dust.', Susan Kaspari, 04 Jan 20142014-01-04T03:28:07+01:00RC C2936: 'The authors do not believe their own numbers.', Anonymous Referee #4, 02 Jan 2014http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2936/2014/tcd-7-C2936-2014.pdfRC C2936: 'The authors do not believe their own numbers.', Anonymous Referee #4, 02 Jan 20142014-01-02T21:54:43+01:00RC C2853: 'Need further works before the acceptance.', Anonymous Referee #3, 25 Dec 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2853/2013/tcd-7-C2853-2013.pdfRC C2853: 'Need further works before the acceptance.', Anonymous Referee #3, 25 Dec 20132013-12-25T00:34:34+01:00AC C2813: 'Black carbon increase due to deposition vs. melt: analysis of accumulation rate records and black carbon flux', Susan Kaspari, 22 Dec 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2813/2013/tcd-7-C2813-2013.pdfAC C2813: 'Black carbon increase due to deposition vs. melt: analysis of accumulation rate records and black carbon flux', Susan Kaspari, 22 Dec 20132013-12-22T17:23:54+01:00AC C2789: 'Revised figures to more clearly display data trends', Susan Kaspari, 22 Dec 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2789/2013/tcd-7-C2789-2013.pdfAC C2789: 'Revised figures to more clearly display data trends', Susan Kaspari, 22 Dec 20132013-12-22T00:55:00+01:00AC C2786: 'Clarification regarding "contradictory conclusions"', Susan Kaspari, 20 Dec 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2786/2013/tcd-7-C2786-2013.pdfAC C2786: 'Clarification regarding "contradictory conclusions"', Susan Kaspari, 20 Dec 20132013-12-20T17:55:48+01:00RC C2621: 'new data from important region, analysis has limited utility', Anonymous Referee #2, 03 Dec 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2621/2013/tcd-7-C2621-2013.pdfRC C2621: 'new data from important region, analysis has limited utility', Anonymous Referee #2, 03 Dec 20132013-12-03T05:39:13+01:00RC C2390: 'Well written paper without substantive conclusions', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Nov 2013http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/7/C2390/2013/tcd-7-C2390-2013.pdfRC C2390: 'Well written paper without substantive conclusions', Anonymous Referee #1, 16 Nov 20132013-11-16T05:44:54+01:00